Conversation with Chapman about Evolutionary DAOs

This episode of the "Green Pill" podcast discusses Chase Chapman's views on evolutionary DAOs, digital identity, and creating a better society through Web3 technology. The podcast explores how simple systems evolve into complex systems, the balance between strategic direction and experiential adaptation, the role of reputation systems, and the potential of DAOs in promoting innovation and social welfare.

GreenPIll

Guests#

Chase Chapman is a governance researcher at Orca Protocol, a well-known figure in the Web3 community, and hosts the "On the Other Side" podcast. She is known on Twitter for discussing evolutionary biology, cooperative games, and the development of better societies through decentralized systems. Her work focuses on understanding and improving the governance structures of DAOs, particularly how these organizations evolve over time to become more effective and impactful.

TL;DR#

Evolutionary Organizations: Gaul's Law states that complex systems evolve from simple systems. This principle is crucial for understanding the development and improvement of DAOs.

Evolutionary Speed: The appropriate timeframe for organizational iteration varies depending on the specific aspects being tested. Different processes require different durations of experiential knowledge and a priori knowledge: DAOs excel in rapidly changing environments because they rely on experiential knowledge, contrasting with theoretical a priori knowledge.

Balance: Successful DAOs must balance clear strategic direction with experiential adaptation while maintaining flexibility and goal orientation. Reputation systems: Reputation systems are essential for fostering trust and cooperative interactions within DAOs. These systems help ensure accountability and trust among members.

Public Goods: Funding public goods is a key goal within the Web3 ecosystem. This approach prioritizes social welfare over purely financial gains.

Trustware vs. Socialware: Effective DAOs need to balance automated trust mechanisms (trustware) with human-centered trust systems (socialware).

Digital Cities: DAOs have the potential to replicate the innovations and opportunities traditionally found in physical cities, creating accessible and innovative digital communities.

🗣️ Evolutionary Organizations and Gaul's Law#

Chase Chapman introduces Gaul's Law, which states that complex systems evolve from simple systems. This principle is vital for understanding the development of DAOs. By starting with simple systems and iterating towards complexity, DAOs can maintain flexibility and test hypotheses, a core concept in organizational studies. Gaul's Law emphasizes the necessity of building complexity on existing simple systems, highlighting that over-engineered systems often fail due to untested assumptions. This approach ensures that DAOs can adapt and evolve in response to real-world feedback, aligning with adaptive processes discussed in organizational sociology. Chapman elaborates on the trend of designing extremely complex systems from the outset within the DAO ecosystem and the broader cryptocurrency context, which can lead to failure due to unrealistic assumptions about user behavior. The organizational flexibility discussed by Orca Protocol involves evolving from simple systems to more complex ones, continuously testing hypotheses and adjusting accordingly. This iterative approach helps avoid over-engineered solutions that cannot operate in practice.

Chapman explains that Gaul's Law is not just a theoretical concept but a practical guideline observed in various successful systems. For instance, many successful technologies and organizations start with a simple core idea and then expand their capabilities as they gain more understanding and resources. This incremental approach allows for identifying and addressing issues at a manageable scale before they escalate into larger problems. In the context of DAOs, this means starting with a simple governance structure and gradually introducing more complex mechanisms as the organization grows and learns from experience. This method is crucial for avoiding the pitfalls of inefficiency or uncontrollability due to excessive complexity.

🗣️ Experiential Knowledge and Organizational Adaptability#

Chapman contrasts experiential knowledge derived from real-world testing with a priori knowledge based on theoretical deduction. DAOs excel in rapidly changing environments because they rely on experiential knowledge, allowing them to adapt effectively. This experiential approach is vital for organizational adaptability and is an important point in organizational studies. The ability to test and iterate hypotheses is crucial for DAOs, as it allows these organizations to respond to new information and changing conditions, ensuring their long-term viability and success. Chapman discusses the importance of recognizing the reality that perfect prediction is impossible. Therefore, launching simple systems and iterating towards more complex solutions is essential. She cites the evolutionary process of Gitcoin, which included various experiments such as bounties, NFTs, and Gitcoin Grants, all tested before finding a successful model. This evolutionary process emphasizes the need for DAOs to adjust their strategies based on experiential feedback from their environments.

Experiential knowledge allows DAOs to remain flexible and responsive to real-world conditions. This is particularly important in the rapidly changing and often unpredictable environments of Web3 and blockchain technology. Experiential knowledge is gained through a process of trial and error, testing different approaches in practice to see which yields the best results. This iterative process helps refine and improve the structure and processes of organizations over time. Chapman notes that this approach sharply contrasts with relying on theoretical models and assumptions that may not hold in the real world. By prioritizing experiential knowledge, DAOs can build more robust and adaptable systems to navigate changing environments.

🗣️ Strategic Direction and Experiential Adaptation#

This episode of the podcast also emphasizes the necessity for DAOs to balance strategic direction and experiential adaptation. Without a clear direction, DAOs may become aimless and fail to achieve their goals. At the same time, maintaining flexibility and adaptability is crucial for success. This balance is a key point in organizational studies and organizational sociology. Strategic direction provides a roadmap for DAOs, while experiential adaptation ensures that the organization remains responsive to new challenges and opportunities, creating a dynamic and resilient structure. While DAOs benefit from the ability to adapt to their environments, they also need a strategic direction to avoid overreacting. She notes that experiential adaptation allows DAOs to test and refine their strategies, but having a clear goal helps maintain focus and coherence. This balance ensures that DAOs can respond to complex and rapidly changing environments while pursuing their overarching goals.

The strategic direction of a DAO should align with its core mission and values. This consistency helps ensure that all members of the organization work towards the same goals, creating a sense of unity and purpose. At the same time, experiential adaptation allows the organization to remain flexible and responsive to new information and changing environments. This balance between strategic direction and experiential adaptation is key for DAOs to thrive in complex and dynamic environments. By maintaining a clear strategic direction, DAOs can focus on their long-term objectives, while experiential adaptation ensures they can effectively respond to emerging challenges and opportunities.

🗣️ Trust and Reputation Systems in DAOs#

Chapman explores the role of reputation systems in fostering trust within DAOs. These systems are crucial for creating cooperative interactions and ensuring accountability among members. Reputation systems align with the concepts of trust and reputation in organizational theory, emphasizing their importance in maintaining effective and trustworthy organizations. In DAOs, reputation systems help mitigate the risks associated with anonymous and pseudonymous interactions, fostering a culture of accountability and trust. These systems are vital for the smooth operation of DAOs, as they ensure that members can rely on each other's integrity and contributions. Chapman discusses how reputation systems can be contextual, varying based on specific relationships and interactions within the DAO. For example, the reputation with one group may differ from that with another, highlighting the need for flexible and adaptive reputation systems that can accommodate different contexts and use cases within the DAO ecosystem.

Reputation systems in DAOs often rely on a combination of quantitative and qualitative metrics. Quantitative metrics may include transaction history, contribution records, and other measurable activities, while qualitative metrics may involve peer reviews, endorsements, and other forms of social validation. By combining these two types of metrics, DAOs can create a more comprehensive and nuanced picture of member reputations. This approach helps ensure that reputation systems are fair and reflect the true value and contributions of each member. Chapman also emphasizes the importance of transparency in reputation systems, as transparency helps build trust and accountability within the organization. By making reputation data publicly accessible, DAOs can create an environment where members feel recognized and valued for their contributions.

🗣️ Public Goods and Cooperative Games#

This section discusses the importance of funding public goods and creating regenerative systems, emphasizing the significance of designing systems that prioritize social welfare over purely financial gains. By funding public goods, DAOs can contribute to creating a better society, ensuring their impact extends beyond financial success. This approach aligns with the principles of cooperative games, where all participants benefit, fostering a more inclusive and sustainable ecosystem. Chapman elaborates on the importance of shifting from financial gains to creating a more livable society. She mentions that the goal of Web3 should be to promote net positive outcomes and avoid situations that could lead to societal decline. The discussion of Ethereum being not just about making you rich but about setting you free serves as a guiding principle for building systems that promote freedom and social welfare.

Funding public goods through DAOs is a way to create value for the entire community, rather than just providing benefits to a select few. Public goods, such as open-source software, educational resources, and community infrastructure, offer benefits that everyone can enjoy. By investing in these types of projects, DAOs can help create a more equitable and sustainable ecosystem. Chapman also emphasizes the importance of designing transparent and inclusive funding mechanisms, ensuring that all members of the community have a voice in decision-making processes. This approach helps build trust and accountability within the organization, as members feel that their contributions are recognized and valued.

🗣️ Trustware and Socialware#

Trustware and socialware are a set of concepts that inspire us to find a balance between automated trust mechanisms and human-centered trust systems. Trustware provides guarantees that do not require social relationships, while socialware relies on trust built through interpersonal interactions. This balance is crucial for the effective operation of DAOs and is a key concept in organizational trust research. Trustware and socialware complement each other, creating a robust framework that allows DAOs to operate efficiently and securely. Trustware ensures the reliability of automated processes, while socialware fosters the interpersonal relationships necessary for collaboration and innovation. For example, a lemonade stand and a vending machine illustrate the distinction between socialware and trustware. A lemonade stand relies on social trust and relationships, while a vending machine operates based on an automated mechanism that does not require trust. In DAOs, balancing these two approaches is essential for effective operation and scalability.

Trustware, such as smart contracts and blockchain technology, provides a secure and transparent way to execute agreements and transactions without intermediaries. These automated systems help reduce the potential for fraud and ensure that all parties adhere to the agreed-upon terms. On the other hand, socialware involves social norms, relationships, and trust established through interpersonal interactions. These social elements are crucial for promoting collaboration and innovation within DAOs. Chapman argues that a successful DAO needs to integrate trustware and socialware to create a strong and resilient organization. By leveraging the strengths of both approaches, DAOs can build systems that are both secure and flexible, capable of adapting to the evolving needs of their members.

🗣️ Digital Cities and Network States#

The analogy between digital spaces and cities highlights the potential of DAOs to replicate the innovations and opportunities traditionally found in physical cities. DAOs can leverage digital technology to create accessible opportunities and foster innovation. This discussion emphasizes the role of DAOs in creating vibrant and innovative digital communities, relevant to both organizational studies and organizational sociology. Digital cities and network states represent the next evolutionary stage of human organization, where digital interactions and collaborations create new possibilities for economic and social development. Chapman discusses how digital spaces create dense networks of interaction, similar to physical cities. She emphasizes the role of repeated interactions and economic systems in promoting innovation and collaboration. By creating digital environments that mimic the density and vibrancy of cities, DAOs can facilitate the emergence of new ideas and opportunities, driving the next wave of innovation in the digital age.

Digital cities can provide the same level of connectivity and collaboration as physical cities, but with the added benefits of accessibility and inclusivity. In digital spaces, people from around the world can come together to share ideas, collaborate on projects, and create new opportunities. This level of connectivity helps break down barriers and create a more inclusive and equitable ecosystem. Chapman also emphasizes the importance of creating economic systems that support innovation and collaboration. By designing economic systems that reward collaboration and innovation, DAOs can create an environment where new ideas can thrive and new opportunities can emerge. This approach helps cultivate a culture of innovation and creativity, driving the next wave of development in the digital age.

📝 Trust and Reputation Systems in DAOs#

This episode concludes with reflections on the evolutionary nature of Web3 systems and the potential of identity and reputation systems to enhance cooperative interactions. Chase Chapman emphasizes the importance of starting with simple systems, learning from past experiences, and iterating towards more complex and adaptive organizations. This approach ensures that DAOs can effectively evolve and adapt to changing environments. By exploring the development, adaptability, and impact of DAOs, this discussion highlights the potential of these organizations to create a better society through innovation and decentralized systems.

Ref

[1] Chase on Twitter:
https://x.com/chaserchapman

[2] Evolutionary Organizations: https://orca.mirror.xyz/Kx2hWV3tr1crlBHy2WBTBdR6Dup76AKHKbpbSzYW2kw

[3] Trustware vs Socialware: https://orca.mirror.xyz/T70CmuhX95ubkw_JHOxSEy8d_EFeYXgtJnF13mPtaZE

[4] Orca Protocol:
https://twitter.com/orcaprotocol
https://x.com/0xMetropolis (after name change)

resource

We are continuously following the latest developments in the GreenPill crypto movement. The "Green Pill" podcast is hosted by Kevin Owocki himself and is also a sub-column of Bankless Youtube. Keeping track of and co-learning from the "Green Pill" podcast is a way to stay at the forefront of the regenerative crypto movement.

Link to this episode of the podcast

Subscribe to the podcast | https://availableon.com/greenpill

The Network State website | https://thenetworkstate.com/ (including books and podcast resources)

take the pill

過往節目

Roaming Public Goods with Vitalik

Discussing Sybil Resistance with Upala Founder Petr Porobov | Green Pill Podcast #36

Talking about the Meta Crisis with Daniel Schmachtenberger | Part One

build

As a Workstream project initiated in the Uncommons community, "Green Pill Podcast Co-learning" adopts a co-creation format, encouraging more people to get involved. Specifically, we are recruiting for the following roles:

Course Representative

Listen to the podcast, produce notes after listening, and publish them on the Uncommons community media account.
It’s not about translation! Instead, it’s about expanding and summarizing based on content understanding.
Share your notes and understanding during co-learning sessions.
Bounty will be distributed based on podcast duration, at 3 USDT per minute.

Typesetter

Typeset based on the content produced by the course representative and column information.

15 USDT per article.

If you are interested in the above roles, feel free to sign up on our Dework page:
https://app.dework.xyz/greenpill

If you are interested in our Workstream, please copy and open our Notion page:

https://greenpillcn.notion.site/GreenPill-62cbfc461cb44fd0a55f62a8104928bc

Our related output content will continue to be published on the Uncommons community's relevant media platforms, so please stay tuned.

Uncommons 02

Uncommons is a public sphere where a collective of Commons Builders explores Crypto Thoughts together.

Uncommons is a public welfare community spontaneously organized by Web3 enthusiasts, social builders, and internet citizens dedicated to building public goods, formerly known as the GreenPill Chinese community.

Notion community collaboration document: https://uncommons.notion.site

Telegram face-to-face digital garden: https://t.me/theuncommons

Twitter Global Publicity: https://twitter.com/Un__commons